Exit Interview Best Practices: Questions to Ask and Why They Matter

When a valuable employee resigns, it's easy to focus on the immediate challenge of backfilling their role. However, the period between their notice and their last day presents a golden opportunity: the exit interview.

An exit interview is more than a formality. It's a powerful diagnostic tool. A departing employee, free from the daily politics and concerns about career progression, is often in a unique position to provide candid, unfiltered feedback about your company's culture, management, and operations.

Conducting these interviews thoughtfully and acting on the insights gained can be one of the most effective ways to improve retention, boost morale, and build a better workplace.

The Goal: Honest Insight, Not a Counteroffer

First, let's be clear about the purpose. The exit interview is not a last-ditch effort to convince the employee to stay. If you wanted to retain them, that conversation should have happened long before they started looking for another job.

The primary goals of an exit interview are:

1. To understand the true reasons for departure.
2. To gather actionable feedback on the company, culture, and role.
3. To end the relationship on a positive and professional note.

Who Should Conduct the Interview?

The ideal person to conduct the exit interview is a neutral and trusted party, typically someone from HR or People Operations.

• Why not the direct manager? The employee's relationship with their direct manager is often a key factor in their decision to leave. They are less likely to be fully honest if they are worried about hurting their manager's feelings or getting a bad reference.
• Why not a skip-level manager? While better than the direct manager, there can still be a power dynamic that inhibits candor.

An HR professional is trained to ask probing questions, listen empathetically, and spot patterns across multiple exit interviews.

Key Exit Interview Questions (and What to Listen For)

The questions you ask should be open-ended and designed to encourage detailed responses. Here are 10 essential questions grouped by theme:

Questions About the Decision to Leave

1. "What prompted you to start looking for a new opportunity?"

   • Why it matters: This gets to the core trigger. Was it a specific event, a gradual dissatisfaction, or simply an opportunity that was too good to pass up? Listen for the "push" factors (what pushed them away from your company) versus the "pull" factors (what pulled them towards the new one).

2. "What were the most important factors in your decision to accept this new role?"

   • Why it matters: This reveals what your competitors are offering that you are not. Is it higher compensation, a better title, more interesting work, or greater flexibility? This is valuable competitive intelligence.

Questions About the Role and Manager

3. "Did you feel you had the tools, resources, and training to be successful in your role?"

   • Why it matters: This uncovers operational friction. Are you under-investing in tools? Is your onboarding process failing? These are often tangible, fixable problems.

4. "Thinking about your relationship with your manager, what did they do that was most helpful for your development, and what could they have done better?"

   • Why it matters: The old adage is true: people leave managers, not companies. This question, framed constructively, can provide invaluable coaching feedback for your managers. Look for patterns. If multiple departing employees mention the same manager, you have a problem to address.

5. "Did you feel your work was recognized and appreciated?"

   • Why it matters: A lack of recognition is a major driver of disengagement. This question helps you gauge whether your culture values and acknowledges employee contributions.

Questions About the Company and Culture

6. "How would you describe our company culture?"

   • Why it matters: This is a broad question designed to elicit their overall perception. Listen to the adjectives they use. Are they positive ("collaborative," "transparent") or negative ("political," "chaotic")?

7. "What did you like most about working here? What did you like least?"

   • Why it matters: This classic question helps you understand your strengths and weaknesses. You want to double down on what people love and start addressing what they don't.

8. "If you could change one thing about our company, what would it be?"

   • Why it matters: This "magic wand" question can often produce surprisingly insightful and creative solutions to problems you may not have even been aware of.

Closing Questions

9. "Would you recommend working here to a friend? Why or why not?"

   • Why it matters: This is the ultimate test of their experience, similar to a Net Promoter Score (NPS). The "why or why not" is the most important part, as it forces them to justify their answer.

10. "Is there anything else you'd like to share that we haven't covered?"

    • Why it matters: This final open door sometimes yields the most important feedback of the entire interview. It gives the employee a chance to bring up any topic they feel is important.

After the Interview: Turning Data into Action

Collecting feedback is useless if you don't do anything with it.

1. Look for Patterns: One person's grievance might be a one-off issue. But if three departing employees from the same team mention the same problem, you have a clear signal that requires action.
2. Synthesize and Share Anonymized Data: Aggregate the key themes and data points from your exit interviews into a quarterly report. Share this anonymized report with the senior leadership team.
3. Create Action Plans: Use the insights to drive real change. If multiple people cite a lack of growth opportunities, perhaps it's time to invest in a learning and development program. If a specific team has high turnover, it may signal a need for management training.
4. Close the Loop: When you do make changes based on exit interview feedback, communicate that back to the company. "We've heard feedback that our onboarding process needs improvement. Based on this, we are implementing a new mentorship program..." This shows your current employees that you are listening and taking their feedback seriously.

Conclusion

An employee's departure is an ending, but it's also a beginning. It's the beginning of your opportunity to learn and improve. By treating the exit interview as a strategic tool for insight, asking thoughtful questions, and, most importantly, acting on the information you receive, you can turn a loss into a long-term gain for your organization.

---

Related Articles:

• [[how-to-resign-professionally-and-gracefully]]
• [[how-to-fire-someone-professionally]]
• [[performance-management-best-practices]]
• [[how-to-handle-underperforming-employees]]